Cost of Owning Music vs Streaming: Which Is Actually Cheaper?

The short answer: Streaming is cheaper today. But over 5+ years, owning physical music wins — and you end up with actual assets instead of a cancelled subscription. Here's the complete financial picture.

The music industry wants you to believe that $12/month is a bargain for "all the music in the world." And for casual listeners, it might be. But if you're someone who loves music — someone who has favorite albums, not just playlists — the economics of ownership start to make a lot more sense.

The True Cost of Streaming in 2026

Let's start with what you're actually paying for streaming. And remember — these prices only go up:

The "+" matters. Streaming prices have increased 20-40% in the last 3 years, and every analyst expects continued hikes. Factor in just 5% annual increases, and that $11.99/month Spotify subscription costs $817 over 5 years, not $720.

What do you own after paying all that? Absolutely nothing. Stop paying, lose everything.

The True Cost of Owning Physical Music

Now let's look at what building a real music collection costs:

CD Collection Costs

Vinyl Collection Costs

Mixed CD + Vinyl Collection (Recommended)

The 5-Year Comparison

Let's compare the most common scenario: an average music fan over 5 years.

Scenario: Spotify Premium for 5 Years

• Total cost (with 5% annual increases): $817
• Music owned after 5 years: 0 albums
• Resale value: $0
• Can you cancel and keep listening? No

Scenario: Building a Physical Collection for 5 Years

Same budget ($817), buying a mix of CDs and vinyl:

• Budget per month: ~$13.60
• Albums purchased (at $16 average): ~51 albums
• Resale value after 5 years: $500-800+
• Can you stop spending and keep listening? Yes, forever

For the same money, you can own 50+ albums forever instead of renting access that vanishes the moment you stop paying.

The 10-Year Comparison

This is where ownership really starts winning:

• Streaming (10 years): ~$1,860 spent, 0 albums owned
• Physical (10 years): ~$1,860 spent, ~116 albums owned

After 10 years, the streamer has a receipt. The collector has a wall of music they can play anytime, pass down to their kids, or sell for potentially more than they paid.

The Hidden Costs of Streaming

The monthly price tag is just the beginning. Streaming has hidden costs that most people overlook:

1. Price Increases Are Guaranteed

Spotify has raised prices every year since 2023. Apple Music, YouTube Music, and Tidal have all followed. There's no ceiling — you're locked into whatever they decide to charge.

2. Music Disappears

Licensing deals expire. Artists pull their catalogs. Regional restrictions block content. That album you loved? It can vanish from your library without warning or compensation.

3. Quality Is Compromised

Even Spotify's "highest quality" (320kbps OGG) is lossy compression. A CD gives you uncompressed 16-bit/44.1kHz audio — exactly what the mastering engineer approved.

4. You're the Product

Streaming services collect data on every song you play, skip, or repeat. They sell that data to advertisers and labels. Your physical collection doesn't spy on you.

5. Zero Resale Value

You can't sell your streaming history. But a well-maintained vinyl collection regularly appreciates in value. Some records are worth 5-10x their original purchase price.

The Hidden Benefits of Owning

Conversely, physical music has value beyond just the music itself:

1. It's an Asset

Vinyl and CDs have resale value. Limited pressings, first editions, and out-of-print albums regularly sell for premiums on Discogs and CD&LP.

2. No Internet Required

Play your records during an internet outage, on a road trip through dead zones, or in a cabin in the woods. Physical media doesn't need Wi-Fi.

3. Rip Once, Stream Forever

Buy a CD, rip it to FLAC, and host it on your own media server (Jellyfin, Navidrome, Plex). You get the streaming experience with zero monthly fees and lossless quality.

4. It's a Legacy

Your vinyl collection can be passed down to children and grandchildren. It's a tangible time capsule of your life and taste. A Spotify account dies with your credit card.

5. Better Artist Support

Artists earn $0.003-0.005 per stream on Spotify. A single $28 vinyl purchase equals approximately 5,600-9,300 streams worth of revenue. Buying physical directly supports the musicians you love.

The "Best of Both Worlds" Strategy

Here's the approach that maximizes value:

1. Keep a free Spotify tier — Use the ad-supported version for music discovery (or skip it entirely and use YouTube).
2. Buy albums you truly love — When you find an album you keep returning to, buy it on CD or vinyl. Use GoOffline to find what's available.
3. Rip your CDs to FLAC — Build your own lossless digital library.
4. Self-host with Navidrome or Jellyfin — Stream your own collection from anywhere, no monthly fee.
5. Redirect your subscription budget — That $12/month buys 1-2 CDs or saves toward vinyl. In a year, that's 12-24 albums you actually own.

This approach costs the same (or less) than a streaming subscription while building a permanent collection with real value.

When Streaming Still Makes Sense

Let's be fair — ownership isn't for everyone or every situation:

• Casual listeners — If you mostly hear background music, streaming is fine
• Music discovery — Exploring new genres and artists is easier on streaming
• Children/teens — Their taste changes too fast to invest in physical
• Extremely limited space — Tiny apartments with no shelf space

But if you have favorite albums — music that means something to you — owning those albums is always the smarter financial and emotional play.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many albums do I need to break even vs. streaming?

With CDs at $10 average: about 14 albums equals one year of Spotify Premium ($144). After that, every album is "free" compared to what you'd keep paying for streaming.

Don't CDs and vinyl wear out?

CDs are practically indestructible if handled reasonably — they last 50-100+ years. Vinyl lasts decades with proper care (clean records, quality stylus, proper storage).

What about the cost of a turntable?

A solid entry-level turntable costs $100-200. It's a one-time investment that lasts years. Check our best entry-level turntables guide. If budget is tight, start with CDs — no equipment needed.

Can I use GoOffline to see prices before buying?

Yes! GoOffline shows estimated CD and vinyl prices for every album in your Spotify playlist. It's free, instant, and requires no signup.

Make the Switch (Or Start Small)

You don't have to go all-in today. Start by converting one Spotify playlist to physical media. See how it feels to hold an album you truly own. Then decide if you want to keep going.

Paste your favorite playlist into GoOffline and see what your music would cost to own — on vinyl, CD, or both.

Check My Playlist →